With Sabrina having to make her final college decision after receiving all her acceptances, the people in her life pressure her to go with their choice; Harvey wants her to go to Boston College with him, Josh wants her to join him at Emerson, Zelda wants her to go to her alma mater, Other Realm University, and Hilda wants her to do what she did and backpack across the universe. However, her indecisiveness and need to please everyone causes her to be literally torn apart into four different Sabrinas who each want to please one of the respective people. The four faces meet at the senior prom, where they all took different dates--Zelda, Hilda, Harvey, AND Josh. When Sabrina finally pulls herself together, she announces her decision as to where she will attend college.
Meanwhile, trouble arises in Mr. Kraft and Zelda's relationship.