Roland the Troll returns, still determined to win Sabrina's heart. However, now he is the Equalizer, in charge of balancing things out in the universe. He begins to stalk an annoyed Sabrina, taking something from her when she takes something away from anyone else. Roland puts a spell on Harvey making him not go to the Valentine's Day dance, which annoys Sabrina. After Sabrina accidentally "steals the heart" of a guy named Ken who Valerie's interested in, Roland uses his authority to steal Sabrina's heart, making her fall madly in love with him. The now lovestruck Sabrina leaves school, and cant keep her eyes off Roland, and heads to the Other Realm with Roland to get married upon which her heart will be sealed and she'll be transformed into his true love permanently. She sees a photo of his old girlfriend Thumbelina, and tells Roland 'the picture has to go you're all mine now" She begins to make him "ecstatically happy" and she also says "I love it here, I love this moldy home, I love Roland". When Roland was told to return her heart Sabrina said "No I don't want it back, I want my Rolly to keep it forever and ever."
Desperate for Valentine's Day dates, Zelda and Hilda summon Cupid, only to discover that he is depressed and has lost his belief in love, until Hilda makes him laugh and is aghast to discover that he is now Mr. Kraft's rival for her reluctant affections.
This is Roland's second appearance in the show, the first being in Troll Bride. This is Cupid's second appearance, appearing first in Dummy for Love.
The audience learns (as far as the show is concerned) that Cupid doesn’t need to necessarily shoot arrows...he can actually hurl "love peas" at people to make them fall in love.
