When Libby and her friends start spreading lies around school about Sabrina and Jenny, Sabrina decides to use her magic to set things straight. She does this by pouring "truth sprinkles" from her magic cupboard in the cakes that they are baking in school. The sprinkles soon cause many blunt and hurtful truths to come out. The sprinkles make Jenny reveal she's sweet on Sabrina's love interest, Harvey. Sabrina has to find a way to bring everything to normal again.
- Melissa Joan Hart as Sabrina Spellman
- Nick Bakay as Salem Saberhagen
- Caroline Rhea as Hilda Spellman
- Beth Broderick as Zelda Spellman
- Nate Richert as Harvey Kinkle
- Jenna Leigh Green as Libby Chessler
- Michelle Beaudoin as Jenny Kelley
- Ella Joyce as Mrs. Bogzigian
- Melissa Murray as Cee Cee
- Bridget Flanery as Jill
- Eddie Allen as a Guidance Counselor
- Ariel Felix as a teacher
- Tom McGowan as Principal Larue
- Curtis Andersen as a student Gordie
- Phillip Glasser as a student
Uses of Magic
- Sabrina uses a spell to pull rabbit out of a hat.
- Hilda conjures in mid air flashing red neon arrow that points at her.
- Sabrina makes napkin fold itself into rose.
- Zelda opens a section of wall.
- Hilda changes her outfit in damsel in distress outfit.
- Hilda changes her outfit in tough chick outfit.
- Hilda changes her outfit in tough chick in distress outfit.
- Sabrina pulls rabbits out of a hat.
To Pull A Rabbit Out Of A Hat
- (Cast by Sabrina Spellman)
- (mentioned by Zelda Spellman)
- Affix the taste organ of a humped ruminant adjacent to one's dentition
- Truth Sprinkles
- Hilda (to Sabrina): Oh no, you look unhappy... Tell Zelda, I can't let you bring me down.
- Zelda: The truth can have some unpleasant side effects. Itching, chafing, hurt feelings...
- Sabrina: Sounds like gym class.
- The fourth outfit for this show's credits is a "mod" red dress and outfit with a purse made out of a stuffed cat. Sabrina says, "As if!"
- Mr. Pool does not appear in this episode.
- Though Hilda's date with Drell is a major subplot, Drell does not actually appear in this episode.
- This episode marks the first appearance of the Slicery.
- Although his character is not named, this episode features the first appearance of Curtis Andersen as Gordie.
- At the end of this episode, Sabrina places all of the bunnies that she has zapped to the Spellman house, back into the top hat that they came out of. Their names were: Trisha, Samantha, Brian, Bernadette and Chloe. Interestingly. Trisha, Samantha, and Brian are all family members of Melissa Joan Hart; Bernadette and Chloe may be as well.
- Emma makes an uncredited, unreferenced appearance, in Home Ec class.